Where Does Parkinson’s Disease Start? In the Brain or Gut? Or Both?
Scientists hypothesize that Parkinson’s disease can be divided into two subtypes: brain-first, and gut-first
November 7, 2019
Amsterdam, NL – Does Parkinson's disease (PD) start in the brain or the gut? In a new contribution published in the Journal of Parkinson's Disease, scientists hypothesize that PD can be divided into two subtypes: gut-first, originating in the peripheral nervous system (PNS) of the gut and spreading to the brain; and brain-first, originating in the brain, or entering the brain via the olfactory system, and spreading to the brainstem and peripheral nervous system.
Per Borghammer, MD, PhD, DMSc, Nuclear Medicine & PET, Aarhus University Hospital, Denmark, and Nathalie Van Den Berge, MSc, PhD, Department of Clinical Medicine, Aarhus University, Denmark, explore the origins of PD onset. They review the evidence that Lewy body disorders (LBD), including PD and dementia with Lewy bodies (DLB), comprise two distinct subtypes: (1) a gut-first phenotype in which marked damage to the peripheral autonomic nervous system precedes measurable damage to the brain itself, including the dopamine cells; and (2) a brain-first phenotype, in which marked damage to the brain precedes measurable damage to the peripheral autonomic nervous system.
“Evidence from autopsy studies of brains from PD patients has suggested that PD may start in the peripheral nervous system of the gut and nose. The pathology then spreads via the nerves into the brain. However, not all autopsy studies agree with this interpretation,” explained Dr. Borghammer. “In some cases, the brains do not contain pathology at the important ‘entry points’ into the brain, such as the dorsal vagus nucleus at the bottom of the brainstem. The gut-first versus brain-first hypothesis posited in this review provides a scenario that can reconcile these discrepant findings from the neuropathological literature into one single coherent theory about the origins of PD.””The discussion about the origins of PD is often framed as an ‘either-or’, i.e., either all PD cases start in the gut or all cases start in the brain,” added Dr. Van Den Berge. “However, much of the evidence seems compatible with both these interpretations. Thus, we need to entertain the possibility that both scenarios are actually true.”
The review summarizes existing evidence from imaging studies from humans and tissue studies from humans and animal models. The imaging and histology studies are generally compatible with the brain-first vs body-first hypothesis. If this hypothesis is correct, it suggests that PD is more complicated than originally thought. If the disease starts in the gut in only a fraction of patients, it is likely that interventions targeting the gut might only be effective for some PD patients, but not for individuals in which the disease starts in the brain itself.
“If the brain-first vs body-first hypothesis is correct, we need to intensify the research into understanding risk factors and triggering factors for these two subtypes,” noted Dr. Van Den Berge.
“It is probable that these different types of PD need different treatment strategies,” commented Dr. Borghammer. “It may be possible to prevent the ‘gut-first’ type of PD through interventions targeting the gut, such as probiotics, fecal transplants, and anti-inflammatory treatments. However, these strategies might not work with respect to treating and preventing the brain-first type. Thus, a personalized treatment strategy will be required, and we need to be able to identify these subtypes of PD in the individual patient.”
PD is a slowly progressive disorder that affects movement, muscle control and balance. It is the second most common age-related neurodegenerative disorder affecting about three percent of the population by the age of 65 and up to five percent of individuals over 85 years of age. During the 20th century, PD was thought to be primarily a brain disorder characterized mainly by loss of pigmented dopaminergic neurons residing in the substantia nigra, a basal ganglia structure located in the midbrain that plays an important role in reward and movement. More recently, it has become clear that PD is highly varied and probably consists of several subtypes.
NOTES FOR EDITORS
Full open access study: “Brain-First versus Gut-First Parkinson’s Disease: A Hypothesis” by Per Borghammer, MD, PhD, DMSc, and Nathalie Van Den Berge, MSc, PhD (DOI: 10.3233/JPD-191721). The article is published in the Journal of Parkinson’s Disease, Volume 9, Supplement 2 entitled “The Gut-Brain Axis in Parkinson’s Disease Revisited,” Guest Editor Teus van Laar, MD, PhD, Director, Parkinson Expertise Center Groningen, Department of Neurology, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, The Netherlands. It is openly available at: content.iospress.com/articles/journal-of-parkinsons-disease/jpd191721.
This paper was supported by the Lundbeck Foundation.
For additional information and requests for interviews contact Diana Murray, IOS Press (+1 718-640-5678 or email@example.com). To reach the authors for comment contact Per Borghammer (firstname.lastname@example.org).
About this Supplement to JPD: The Gut-Brain Axis in Parkinson’s Disease
This special supplement to the Journal of Parkinson’s Disease reveals the enormous complexity of the gut-brain axis and demonstrates that there are still unanswered questions. Does PD start in the gut in all patients, or is this potential trigger site relevant only in a small subgroup of patients? What is the role of constipation, and what distinguishes those patients who are not constipated in terms of underlying disease mechanisms? What is the effect of constipation on the microbiome? Does constipation lead to a different subtype of PD? The supplement explores a variety of topics and hopefully will contribute to an improved understanding of the role of the gut in PD, and ultimately stimulate the development of new therapies that improve the lives of patients with PD. This supplement to is openly available at https://content.iospress.com/journals/journal-of-parkinsons-disease/9/s2 or via the short link http://bit.ly/JPD9-s2.
About Journal of Parkinson’s Disease
Launched in 2011, the Journal of Parkinson’s Disease (JPD) is dedicated to providing an open forum for original research in basic science, translational research and clinical medicine that will expedite our fundamental understanding and improve treatment of Parkinson’s disease. The journal is international and multidisciplinary and aims to promote progress in the epidemiology, etiology, genetics, molecular correlates, pathogenesis, pharmacology, psychology, diagnosis and treatment of Parkinson’s disease. JPD publishes research reports, reviews, short communications, and letters-to-the-editor and offers very rapid publication and an affordable open access option. journalofparkinsonsdisease.com
About IOS Press
IOS Press is headquartered in Amsterdam with satellite offices in the USA, Germany, India and China and serves the information needs of scientific and medical communities worldwide. IOS Press now publishes more than 80 international peer-reviewed journals and about 75 book titles each year on subjects ranging from computer science, artificial intelligence, and engineering to medicine, neuroscience, and cancer research. iospress.com