Patient Awakes from Post-Traumatic Minimally Conscious State after Administration of Depressant Drug
First Reported Incidence and Possible Implications Published in Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience
December 16, 2014
A patient who had suffered a traumatic brain injury unexpectedly recovered full consciousness after the administration of midazolam, a mild depressant drug of the GABA A agonists family. This resulted in the first recorded case of an “awakening” from a minimally-conscious state (MCS) using this therapy. Although similar awakenings have been reported using other drugs, this dramatic result was unanticipated. It is reported in Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience.
Traumatic brain injuries occur at high rates all over the world, estimated at 150-250 cases per 100,000 population per year. These injuries can result in several outcomes, ranging from vegetative state, minimally conscious state, severe disability to full recovery. In most cases, the outcome will cause catastrophic changes for his/her family and a signiﬁcant drain on both human and ﬁnancial resources.
Two years after the injury caused by a motor vehicle accident, the patient was mildly sedated, in order to undergo a CT scan, using midazolam instead of the more commonly used propofol. As the authors described in the article, the patient began to interact with the anesthetist and soon after with his parents. He talked by cellphone with his aunt and congratulated his brother when he was informed of his graduation; he recognized the road leading to his home. When he was asked about his car accident, he did not remember anything and apparently he was not aware of his condition. This clinical status lasted about two hours after drug administration and disappeared quickly thereafter, taking the patient back to the previous condition.
To further investigate this phenomenon, the researchers collected extensive EEG scans before, during, and after administration of midazolam. Using sophisticated data analysis, they were able to show the locations within the brain where the drug induced changes and followed the onset and the decline of the effects.
They noted that the patient could have also been diagnosed with the classic symptoms of catatonia, based on the similarity of the EEG sometimes observed in that pathology. Catatonia can be a manifestation of a non-convulsive status epilepticus (NCSE). The authors were thus faced with a two-fold mystery: Is this a case of catatonia mimicking a case of MCS or does the MCS, as a syndrome in itself, also include elements of a catatonic nature? Do the relative contributions of MCS versus catatonia in the individual patient determine whether or not he/she will respond to GABA A agonist drugs?
Maria Chiara Carboncini, MD, Medical Director of the Brain Injury Unit, Department of Neuroscience, University Hospital of Pisa and Adjunct Professor, University of Pisa, Italy, states, “Considering the MCS from this point of view could pave the way to new perspectives for both therapy and clinical management: at least a part of MCS patients could in fact beneﬁt from treatment with non-selective GABA A agonists….” She also notes that as a practical consequence, “such patients should be tested not only with GABA A selective drugs like zolpidem, but also with GABA A non-selective drugs like benzodiazepines.”
# # #
NOTES FOR EDITORS
“A case of post-traumatic minimally conscious state reversed by midazolam: Clinical aspects and neurophysiological correlates,” by Maria Chiara Carboncini, Andrea Piarulli, Alessandra Virgillito, Pieranna Arrighi, Paolo Andre, Francesco Tomaiuolo, Antonio Frisoli, Massimo Bergamasco, Bruno Rossi and Luca Bonfiglio. Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience, Volume 32, Number 6, November 2014, DOI 10.3233/RNN-130351. Published by IOS Press.
ABOUT RESTORATIVE NEUROLOGY AND NEUROSCIENCE (RNN)
An interdisciplinary journal under the editorial leadership of Bernhard Sabel, PhD, Restorative Neurology and Neuroscience publishes papers relating the plasticity and response of the nervous system to accidental or experimental injuries and their interventions, transplantation, neurodegenerative disorders and experimental strategies to improve regeneration or functional recovery and rehabilitation. Experimental and clinical research papers adopting fresh conceptual approaches are encouraged. The overriding criteria for publication are novelty, significant experimental or clinical relevance and interest to a multidisciplinary audience.
RNN Editorial Office
Prof. Dr. Bernhard Sabel
Institut für Medizinische Psychologie
Otto-v.-Guericke Universität Magdeburg
ABOUT IOS PRESS
Commencing its publishing activities in 1987, IOS Press serves the information needs of scientific and medical communities worldwide. IOS Press now (co-)publishes over 100 international journals and about 75 book titles each year on subjects ranging from computer sciences and mathematics to medicine and the natural sciences.
IOS Press continues its rapid growth, embracing new technologies for the timely dissemination of information. All journals are available electronically and an e-book platform was launched in 2005.
Headquartered in Amsterdam with satellite offices in the USA, Germany, India and China, IOS Press has established several strategic co-publishing initiatives. Notable acquisitions included Delft University Press in 2005 and Millpress Science Publishers in 2008.